Cycling for Health
  • Home
  • Bruce's Blog
  • Tony Marchesini remembered
  • Southwark Healthy Rides
    • Next ride
    • Healthy Ride Reports Oct-Dec 2018
    • Healthy Ride Reports Jan-March2019
  • Other Rides
    • Bexley Healthy Rides
  • Traffic and Junctions
    • Hold-the-Left Junctions
  • Cycling Statistics
    • London Cycling Performance
  • Evidence Base
  • Cycle training
  • Cycle Repair
  • How fit am I?
  • Cycle Routes in and around Southwark
  • Links
  • Miscellaneous
    • Connect 2 Southwark
    • Grange Get Cycling

Southwark's Try-and-Ride Scheme

30/9/2017

0 Comments

 
Southwark council's cheap bike loan scheme is not found by searching the Southwark web site or the site of Cycle Confident who run the scheme.  This is very puzzling. This is a very good scheme for getting people started or restarted in cycling.  Please let us know your experience with the scheme by Commenting on this blog post.
0 Comments

Active travel in different ethnic groups

12/9/2017

0 Comments

 
Key points
  • It is being claimed that Active Travel is lower in people of White British origin compared with those of Afro-Caribbean or Asian origin.
  • The basis of these claims is data from the Active People Survey.
  • Other, better-designed, surveys indicate that the white British grouping actually does more active travel than other groups.
  • It is important that we do not design programmes to increase active travel that focus on the wrong people.
  • All ethnic groups need to be encouraged to increase their active travel. 
  • For cycling particular incentives need to be devised to get a higher proportion of Black and Asian groups into active travel by bike.
 
In the recent report on “Active Travel in Southwark 2017 - The health economic impact of walking and cycling (Southwark’s Joint Strategic Needs Assessment)” it was stated “People from White British ethnicity are least likely to take up active travel”.  This information was going to play a part in targeting Southwark’s efforts to increase active travel.  The source of this statement was a publication by the Dept for Transport, Local Area Walking and Cycling Statistics: England, 2014/15.   In turn, this data was derived from the Active People Survey (APS) conducted by Sport England.  

Picture
My understanding from other surveys of cycling and walking was that across the main ethic groupings, there was a higher proportion of cyclists in the white grouping and about the same walking rate across all groups.  My concern was that the Active People Survey data might be unreliable, yet was likely to guide policy.  This report re-examines at data from other surveys.  The opportunity was also taken to look at London and Southwark, not just the national picture.
 
National Travel Survey (NTS)
This is the Dept of Transport’s annual survey of approximately 15000 individuals.  The focus is on trips made for “transport” reasons.  The proportions cycling once per month are much higher than the “Utility” data shown above from the AP Survey.  This may be because the NTS sets broader criteria for transport riding than the APS did for “utility” riding. 
The NTS data shows cycling in both black and Asian groups is well below the level in the white group.  The pattern in London is the same as for Great Britain as a whole.

 
Picture
London Travel Demand Survey (LTDS)
This is a household interview survey carried out by Transport for London.  8000 face-to-face interviews are carried out each year, and interviewees also fill out a 1 day travel diary.  All travel is covered, but leisure trips only account for 25% of the total, so the data represents largely “utility” cycling.
Analysis of trip mode shares gives the clearest indication of relative amounts cycing and walking done by different ethnic groups.  Data was available for 9 years, 2005-2013.
 

Picture
Picture
Trip rate for the white British group is 3 to 4 times higher than for black or Asian groupings.  This was true for Inner London and for Southwark.  Data for Asians in Southwark is not plotted as the sample was too small.
The situation for walking is different.  Walking trip rates are much more stable over time and differ little between ethnic groups

Picture
Census 2011 The census asks everyone about their main mode of transport to work.
Picture
Picture
Obviously transport to work is “utility”.  The same pattern emerges as is seen in the NTS and LTDS.  Cycling in the white British ethnic group is about 3 times the level in Asian or black ethnic groups. This is true at local, Southwark, level and at national level.  Walking is more uniform, but there is still a clear trend for white British to walk to work more than Asian or black ethnic groups.

Why is the Active People Survey so out of line?
 The Active People Survey is a random digit phone survey.  This gives large numbers, but depends on reaching people via land lines.  Large segments of the population have no land line, for example many young people.  The APS survey team will try to compensate for this, but they have never published their method for doing so.  As land lines have become less used, this problem can only have become more difficult to deal with.  This methodology has in fact now been abandoned and a postal/internet survey with a proper population sample, Active Lives, has replaced the APS.
 
The other problem is with the question.  Many people will find it difficult to distinguish “utility” from “leisure” cycling.  It is notable that if you combine the APS data on utility and leisure cycling you end up with a situation closer to the other surveys.

 
Conclusions
The idea that white British are the ethnic group to target to increase active travel is clearly wrong.  All ethnic groups need to be encouraged to increase their active travel.  And for cycling particular incentives need to be devised to get a higher proportion of Black and Asian (and probably some other minorities) into active travel by bike.

Downloadable copy of above blog in Word format below

active_travel_in_ethnic_groups_critique.doc
File Size: 224 kb
File Type: doc
Download File

0 Comments

    Author

    I run short "healthy rides" for Southwark Cyclists. Have a background in exercise science.

    Archives

    January 2019
    October 2018
    November 2017
    September 2017
    April 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    July 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    July 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.